Search the Taxacom archive · Browse by month · Mirror of the former lists.ku.edu archive (1992–2025)

Yesterday the yellow brick road.

John Grehan jrg13 at PSU.EDU
Thu Aug 12 23:05:31 CDT 1999


Kipling Will wrote:

>I definitely agree with John that evolution is quite often wrongly
>presented as empirical fact.

I would add that I think its wrong to concentrate on evolution as
either theory or fact. Rather, I believe that the focus of evolutionary
teaching should be on methodology and research programs. I seem
to be in a very tiny minority with that view.

>There is no equivalence between "belief in God" (their particular one),
>an untestable and empirically empty concept, and evolution as an
>explanatory scientific hypothesis (I think a really good explanation).
>Somehow we have to convince people that these are not interchangeable
>and each has an appropriate way and place to be taught.

In my view teaching evolution as scientific methodology rather than
a dogmatic assertion of history might go some way to achieving this.
In the sense that yesterday (even the event a moment ago) is no longer
"empricial" reality, any account of the past might be considred as
untestable and empirically empty as that of god.

John Grehan






More information about the Taxacom mailing list